The theological-political mindset and mutual harm

M. Bitar George Banna:

Jadaliyya - Do-For-Self: The Visual Culture of the Nation of IslamThe historical mistake of the Arabs since the Great Fitna was mixing theology with politics, which was manifested in the personality of the Caliph, who combined them in his person. In the context of that mixture or combination, the old theology was able to dominate the present at the hands of different parties and groups such as the Brotherhood, the Baath, and the Arabists. Theology was that drum pulled by the mule of politics, and politics was that drum pulled by the mule of theology. The result was, and until now, bad results, nihilism, absurdity, failure, backwardness, then endless violence and wars.

The mixing and entanglement harmed the political and the theological alike, and as a result led to the ossification of each of them. The jurists moved at times to support fixed political slogans such as the slogan of one Arab nation, the great Arab people, reviving Arab glories, etc., and the political authority moved at other times to enshrine the theological aims of the jurists, for example, influencing the personal status law, or teaching the subject of religion in schools, then the third article of the constitution regarding the religion of the head of state, in addition to emphasizing that Sharia is the source of the constitution, etc. That is, the dominance of religious Sharia was done with the help of politics, and the dominance of the men of political authority was done by the men of jurisprudence and Sharia. As a result, each of them froze the other and each of them harmed the other.

They took turns taming the people with leaps of accusations. On the political side, there were accusations of treason, collaboration, reactionism, selling out the cause, betrayal, etc. On the theological side, there were counter-accusations whose content was excommunication, accusations of heresy, apostasy, and other things. All of these were ready-made theological accusations that expressed political differences, and the accusations of the other side were ready-made political accusations that expressed theological differences. Criticism of the leaders, for example, was in its essence theological, but it was wrapped in a political guise. That leadership was politically bad because of its theological affiliation. Thus, the Brotherhood opposed any leadership that did not belong to their theology on the pretext that the leadership was attacking freedom and democracy, without being embarrassed that they were, in principle, the first and fiercest enemies of freedom and democracy.

Even the Israel-Palestine problem has been subject to the same principle. Many turbaned men claim that the enmity with Israel has no relation to the occupation of Palestine, but rather to the Banu Qurayza and the descendants of Banu Qurayza. In doing so, they transfer the conflict from the sectarian past to the political present, on the assumption that the Israeli-Palestinian problem is a political problem in the first place. On the other hand, the position of the Brotherhood, which supported and endorsed the occupation of northern Syria by Erdogan, was political in form and theological in essence. The occupation is a political matter, while the essence of loyalty and disavowal in the issue of occupation is theological. The Palestinian-Israeli political problem is seen by some from the perspective of disbelief and faith. Those who occupied Palestine were disbelievers, in addition to being, from the market perspective, monkeys and pigs.

Understanding and solving the Palestinian problem requires a rational, ethical, and political intellectual stance that can be discussed. The foolish discourse regarding the sons of apes and pigs or disbelief cannot be discussed. These are monologues dating back 1440 years, monologues whose aim is to stir up emotions and religious and ethnic racism. Monologues are not the product of reason, and the solution to the problem can only be achieved through reason!

The entanglement and intersection of theology with politics is one of the most important problems in the Arab world. Political action is not of the same nature as theological action, and it contradicts its axioms and is not consistent with it. In light of this antagonistic entanglement, a distorted concept has grown in the Arab consciousness regarding the concept of the state, which has been pulled in some directions by somewhat modern concepts derived from secularism, and by tribal Bedouin concepts with a theological tinge, which remained in their broad outlines after the birth of the call as they were before it.

The crisis of the past is similar to the crisis of the present. In the past, the Saqifa gathering failed to present the hadith, which led to the old tribal mentality taking over the minds of the Saqifa group and the concept of the nation. In this era, the present has failed to prove itself with new ideas and practices, which paved the way for the old heritage to occupy the present. In the past, there were Kharijites, and in the present, there are Kharijites. There is a kind of loyalty to what has accumulated in minds from bad practices, such as extremism, confiscation of rights, ideas, and freedoms, and returning to texts to legitimize evil practices.

A person becomes frustrated because of the decline that has afflicted the Arabs, a decline that has clothed both theology and politics in the garb of the other. The answer to the political question has become theological and vice versa. The takbir (Allahu Akbar) has been accompanied by cannon fire as twins, as a theological-political tendency or system, whose only concern is to produce a totalitarian, herd-like mentality that is theologically rigid and politically dictatorial.

See less

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *