The state of stagnation in dialogue

 Mamdouh Bitar Syriano:
40+ Adult Illiteracy Illustrations - iStock    Many in this region call for national unity and the unification of efforts to overcome crises and revive wounded or dead homelands, Despite the complete agreement among the people of these nations on the subject of national unity and the unification of efforts for revival, we see nothing of the revival that is the urgent demand of the masses, So what is the reason for this discrepancy between the will of everyone and what everyone has achieved in terms of weakness, decline, and backwardness?
First, we want to emphasize that national unity has different levels, and the level that can be a common denominator for everyone is the will for the good and progress of the country, Anything else has no relation to national unity, There is no national unity regarding the vision, no national unity regarding the position, no understanding of problems, and not even their solution! These levels are the levels of creative difference, and maintaining difference at these levels is one of the most important necessities, because a unified thought is sterile, and a unified position is in itself a dictatorship, or it only comes from dictatorships, or it allows dictatorship to ride on it, We are surprised here by the background of those orphaned calls, as there is no similar thing to them in societies that have progressed and solved their problems and crises. Progress is the translation of overcoming trials and crises, Advanced societies can solve their problems with the presence of creative difference capable of devising the best solutions to the greatest problems.
The utopian concept of national unity has been transformed into a breeding ground for exploitation, manipulation, belittling, and distortion, For the sake of this vague illusion of national unity, practices have been undertaken that have no relation to the good of the country; quite the contrary. Who among the Arabs practices this captivating patriotism? Arabs are among the peoples of the world who talk the most about unity, and among the most divisive and hypocritical, They are among the peoples of the world who talk the most and boast about patriotism, the greatness of the nation, and the Bedouin culture that has never ceased to illuminate the path of humanity throughout the past centuries, Yet, they are among the most treacherous, dark, and unjust of God’s creatures. They illuminated the world with civilization, despite being entirely oral 1400 years ago, and they continue to illuminate the world with 50% of them being illiterate. According to UNESCO, they read no more than a page a year, compared to the average Briton reading fifty books a year, Imagine the state of humanity in terms of enlightenment and progress if the Arabs were able to read and write!
Productive political action cannot take place without interaction between different political groups, and interaction only takes place in the embrace of difference and freedom. The required unity of opinion does not require any interaction. Here, a single opinion is usually imposed within the framework of coercion and the domination of one party over another, a situation that breeds tension and thus conflict that may develop into wars, Some of the Brotherhood call for unity of opinion and position, but in practice, they mean positioning everyone under their intellectual umbrella, Thus, they consider terrorism, that is, the terrorism of ISIS, Al-Qaeda, and others, a glorious revolution, and supporting this glorious revolution is a self-evident matter for every patriot. Anything else has no relation to patriotism.
National identity is not based solely on what unites people, but also on what distinguishes them from one another, National unity has a certain narrow level, All Arabs want progress for their countries, and as a national unity, that is sufficient, What can be metaphorically called “unity” lies in pluralism, which includes difference. Everyone wants the nation to progress, and progress has conditions, including investing in difference in a project to devise effective ways and means to achieve this progress,Unity of opinion means the death of opinion, unity of position means no position, unity of vision means no vision, because the correct vision is not born without interaction within difference, We feel that demanding unity of opinion is like demanding a single dictator who imposes a single opinion and direction, which ferments in his mind and is born from his mind, and not from the interaction of different opinions and directions, Interaction produces what is correct and best, The singularity of opinion and non-interactive directions usually produce the wrong opinion and direction.
What unites the peoples of the region’s entities is nothing but the desire for a stable and prosperous life, The peoples of the Middle East region have not been able to create a definition of state identity, nor of sources of legislation, nor of anything else, The reason is their inability to interact with each other, The ability to interact presupposes the ability to engage in dialogue within the framework of difference. In these countries, people do not engage in dialogue with each other, but rather they conspire against each other, or they order each other around, or they lie to each other.
In general, it can be said that the diversity of opinions, positions, and viewpoints is a good, necessary, and vital thing. In fact, viewpoints cannot exist without diversity when there is freedom of opinion. The deficiency lies in the interaction that takes place in dialogue, No better ideas are produced than those already in our minds because our minds do not interact or engage in dialogue,This is a state of stagnation that ends in nothingness…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *