Observations regarding religion and the state from the perspective of the Syrian Social Nationalist Party

M. Bitar,  Ruba Mansor

Opinion | Syrians Vote Amid Violence - The New York Times It is no secret that a trend has emerged in all Arabic-speaking entities toward entrenching nationalism, distancing themselves from Arabism and Arab nationalist thought, This is hardly surprising after a century of Arab nationalist failure, The Arab nationalists failed on their own; no one else caused their downfall, If the concept of conspiracy truly exists, it is because they conspired against themselves and brought about their own downfall, They were given more time than they needed and more opportunities than necessary,The people trusted them, only to be met with disappointment. The culmination was the complete destruction of the countries they were meant to build, the complete fragmentation of the countries they were meant to unite, and the complete impoverishment of the people they were meant to feed, These people have been reduced to herds of beggars, refugees, and escapees. Therefore, there is a need for reconstruction, which will inevitably clash with other interests,Reconstruction is a monumental task, impossible to accomplish in a year or even ten, Repairing what has been corrupted requires a century or even centuries of tireless work and the highest levels of political, social, and economic expertise, So where did we get that summit from?

 A professional summit cannot be manufactured in a week or a month. Most likely, those who will carry out future tasks will be derived from the current ones after sifting through them, developing what is suitable for development, and discarding what cannot be developed. Here, it is worth noting the importance of the international community in making decisions regarding the future of Syria. Syria is no longer completely independent to be able to make independent decisions. Syria has become a mob-like colony, and others must sort out its affairs. And have the Syrians proven any ability to manage their country in the last century?

 The foundation for the success of any internal party or political system in contributing to the future reconstruction process lies in the alignment of its program with the international will, which holds the final say. We have witnessed the features of this international will on more than one occasion, There is no need to reiterate what the international will desires, as it is well-known to all, such as the implementation of Security Council Resolution 2254 and others, followed by the threat   of applying Article VII of the UN Charter, in addition to providing or withholding material aid, etc.

 What does the Syrian political party scene currently offer in terms of political party systems and formations from which something can be derived to serve the Syrian future in light of the inevitable rise of Syrian nationalism?

 There are many organizations in Syria, some of which are almost dead and some of which are waiting to die, The Ba’ath, with its Arab nationalism, is no longer viable, The Ba’ath has destroyed the Ba’ath, killed it, and mutilated its body in the worst way, The Ba’ath has failed, and there is no need to repeat the failure with the Ba’ath again, There is the Muslim Brotherhood system, which will not find a foothold in the future Syria that is planned to be secular, in addition to the Brotherhood’s utter failure in its practices, which led to the destruction of Syria in partnership with the Arabists,Therefore, the Brotherhood can be practically eliminated, especially after they were placed on the terrorism lists that include criminalizing them, prosecuting them, and fighting them internationally.

  There remains in existence what is old and may be suitable to contribute in the future to the processes mentioned,This old is the Syrian Social Nationalist Party,It is the oldest party in Syria after the Communist Party and has a scientific intellectual base, a very rich intellectual stock and considerable experience, The thought of this party is consistent with the development of the Syrian state towards Greater Syria, and with the gradual distancing from Arabism, So what is this party’s vision regarding the future of Syria and how should this vision be?

 There is a party older than the Syrian Nationalist Party; it is the Internationalist Communist Party, ideologically speaking, but it is organizationally disorganized, Perhaps in this respect, it resembles the Syrian Nationalist Party, There are many communist parties and many Syrian nationalist parties, and it is impossible to identify the reasons that led to the proliferation of communist or Syrian nationalist parties, What is clear is the success of the Assad regime in “personalizing” these parties and thus fragmenting them after separating the individuals from each other, In general, we see the necessity of creating someone to represent the left, even without a communist party!

 The vision of the Syrian Social Nationalist Party stems from its literature, principles, practices, and experience regarding many issues, The first issue must be developing the view of reality, that is, reviewing positions according to reality, such as the view of Cyprus, or the view of Iskenderun, Cilicia, or even Palestine-Israel. Everything that cannot be achieved must be put on hold, There is no need to talk about the areas that were annexed to Turkey or about throwing Israel into the sea, No one can throw Israel into the sea, Therefore, an understanding must be reached with Israel and an agreement made with it in a way that secures for Syria the maximum possible gains, Nothing can be achieved without acknowledging defeat, that is, acknowledging reality.

 The new vision of the Syrian Social Nationalist Party is to strive to establish a renaissance in Syrian society within the framework of Syria, i.e., Sykes-Picot Syria, Here, work must be done on the Syrian identity and on elevating this identity, by demonstrating that it is an incubator, a communicator, and a guarantor   of progress    , It must not compete with other secondary identities such as religious identity, The Syrian identity is the most sublime and appropriate, As Saadeh defined it, the national nation is “a group of people living a life of unified destiny, unified psychological-material factors in a country whose interaction with it, in the course of development, gives it characteristics and advantages that distinguish it from other groups.”

    Saadeh considered the religious state a major problem, Every religious state carries within it the seeds of its own disintegration because it combines contradictions   ,The spiritual function cannot coexist with temporal political power, which is characterized by rapid change and development based on self-interest, The spiritual function is also subject to the dictates of slow development, and in religion, it never evolves, nor can it keep pace with the political function, Ultimately, after conflicts, temporal political power will prevail, as happened in Europe  at the end of the Middle Ages. Saadeh said, “Religion, in its essence, is non-national and contrary to nationalism and nation-building because it is humanistic and universal.” This means that religion is international and does not accept being confined by the political-geographical boundaries of the state, It transcends borders, while the political state is defined by geographical boundaries recognized by the rest of the world,The continuity of a people on their land, defined by the borders of the recognized state, is the fundamental pillar for the survival of that people, There is no life for a people without land, The identity we carry, as well as the passport, indicate, above all else, our geographical status, Where Where we live determines our belonging; neither religion, nor language, nor even ethnicity determines our identity.

   Religious sectarianism stands as an obstacle to building national consciousness and equality among citizens, Therefore, religion must be kept separate from the state, even though religion can play a supporting role for the national principle, especially when everyone adheres to one religion, which is not the case in the world, even in Iran, or when religion is able to transform from a personal identity to a social identity, such as social religion in Europe,However, the situation in Syria is different and the opposite of that, In some Arab entities, religion does not play a supporting role for unity, but rather is a cause of division, discord, and fragmentation, where religion is mixed with the state and rule is done on behalf of God, not on behalf of the people, Moreover, the religious institution’s possession of all the answers to material and spiritual questions makes it possess all kinds of power, Whoever possesses all the answers automatically becomes totalitarian, and whoever possesses all the answers eliminates creative difference and prepares people to practice destructive conflict.

   Merging religion with the state makes it easier to merge religion with science, which leads to reducing science to heresy and disbelief, to a conflict between scientific and religious data, and to the birth of crises. Is humanity the product of the lineage of Adam and Eve, or an evolution from animal to human, an evolution that did not take place in seven days, but rather gradually over tens of thousands of years? Do we have the ability to prove that we are from the lineage of Adam and Eve or from the lineage of monkeys and pigs?  

  Adherence to a religious state leads to conflict between religious groups, and the transformation of the nation’s identity into a religious identity due to the differing references of sectarian religious groups. The nation loses the reference that the sect gains, and thus the transformation occurs from the nation’s sects to a nation of sects, i.e., to a non-nation!

  A democratic state is a nation-state because the people are the source of authority in a nation-state, A democratic state does not represent the past or bygone glory, but rather the interests of the people in the present and future,Saadeh emphasized the necessity of democratic-national awareness for any election to take place, and he presented Lebanon as an example of farcical elections that affect the country’s political situation superficially by changing names, not by changing the underlying principles, Electing a person has no connection to democracy, just as electing a tribal leader does not, The program is what is up for election, not the person, Furthermore, electing an illiterate tribal leader has no connection to democracy, How can an illiterate person defend the interests of his constituents? There can be no elections without first establishing the civil rights of the people, such as the right to think, the right to choose, the right to believe, the right to assemble, and the right to form opinions—not the right to sell votes or the right to submit to terrorism, as in the saying, “You will not enter Paradise unless you vote for Morsi!” Non-citizens have no right to interfere in elections and nominations, Messengers and prophets, including the Creator, are not Syrian citizens, and elections pertain to the earth and not to heaven.

The democracy of happiness is very mature, It is not just a ballot box, but a democratic consciousness and a democracy of awareness, It is not a mechanism to legitimize clan leaders, tribalism, and family ties!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *